Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/whowouldwin icon
r/whowouldwin icon

r/whowouldwin

members
online


Goku (Dragonball) vs Aang (Avatar) - but it's the live action versions from their horrible late-2000's movies Goku (Dragonball) vs Aang (Avatar) - but it's the live action versions from their horrible late-2000's movies
Battle

The two meet each other and for whatever reasons are determined to defeat the other in combat. They meet in the desert, but there is a body of water nearby that Aang can use.


Round1: They fight as they are at the start of the movies

Round2: They fight as they are after their travel/training montages

Round3: They fight as they are in the climax/finale of their movies.


Higher vampire vs homelander Higher vampire vs homelander
Battle

a higher vampire from the witcher vs homelander. Chat gpt seems to think homelander would win.

Hive (Higher Vampire) vs. Homelander

Comparing Hive, a higher vampire from "The Witcher" series, with Homelander from "The Boys" requires examining their abilities, strengths, and weaknesses.

Hive (Higher Vampire)

  • Abilities: Superhuman strength, speed, agility, and near-immortality. Can regenerate from severe injuries and even come back from apparent death.

  • Powers: Ability to transform into more powerful forms, become intangible or invisible, hypnotize or control minds, manipulate shadows, and teleport short distances. Resilient to conventional damage.

  • Weaknesses: Vulnerability to certain magical and alchemical substances (though these are typically known to Witchers).

Homelander

  • Abilities: Superhuman strength, speed, durability, and flight. Near invulnerability to most forms of physical damage.

  • Powers: Possesses heat vision capable of immense destructive power. Enhanced senses, including superhuman hearing and vision. He also has an extraordinary level of physical resilience.

  • Weaknesses: Psychological instability and overconfidence. Vulnerable to certain extreme powers and very high levels of damage, though rarely encountered.

Hypothetical Battle Scenario

  1. Initial Clash: Homelander’s speed and power would give him an initial advantage, allowing him to deliver powerful attacks quickly. Hive’s resilience would enable it to survive initial blows.

  2. Combat Techniques: Homelander’s flight and heat vision provide a significant tactical advantage. Hive’s ability to become intangible or invisible and teleport would make it difficult for Homelander to land continuous hits.

  3. Special Abilities: Hive’s mind control and shadow manipulation could create openings, but Homelander’s enhanced senses might help counteract these abilities to some extent.

  4. Regeneration and Endurance: Hive’s near-immortality and rapid regeneration would be crucial in a prolonged fight. Homelander’s durability and near invulnerability would keep him in the battle, but his lack of regenerative ability like Hive’s could be a factor.

  5. Psychological Warfare: Hive’s hypnotic abilities might be less effective against Homelander’s mental instability, but Hive could exploit Homelander’s overconfidence and psychological weaknesses.

Conclusion

In a direct, one-on-one battle:

  • Hive (Higher Vampire): Hive's near-immortality, regeneration, and supernatural abilities like intangibility, invisibility, and shadow manipulation provide significant advantages. Its resilience and ability to come back from apparent death make it an incredibly tough opponent.

  • Homelander: Homelander’s superhuman strength, speed, durability, flight, and heat vision make him a formidable adversary. His near invulnerability to most physical damage and his ability to attack from a distance provide strategic advantages.

Outcome

The battle would be intense and highly dependent on tactics and circumstances. Here’s the breakdown:

  • Strength and Speed: Homelander has a clear advantage in raw strength and speed, combined with the ability to fly and attack from a distance using heat vision.

  • Regeneration and Resilience: Hive’s ability to regenerate and recover from almost any damage would be crucial, especially against Homelander’s powerful attacks. However, Homelander’s near invulnerability would make him extremely difficult to injure in the first place.

  • Supernatural vs. Physical: Hive’s supernatural abilities could pose unique challenges, but Homelander’s physical dominance and lack of typical weaknesses exploited by Hive might limit these advantages.

Winner: Homelander, but it would be a high-difficulty battle due to Hive's resilience and supernatural abilities. Homelander's overwhelming physical power, flight, and heat vision would likely give him the edge in the end, especially if he maintains a relentless assault and avoids getting caught in Hive's more esoteric abilities.




Postal dude (POSTAL) vs Crypto (Destroy all human's) Postal dude (POSTAL) vs Crypto (Destroy all human's)
Battle

connection: both are really destructive main protagonist's in there games, they kill alot of people, and cause chaos where-ever they go.

plot of the battle: Crypto is sent by Orthopox to kill postal dude, because he is a threat to crypto and pox's mission to enslave all earthling's, crypto tracks down postal dude, he trys to kill him on the spot but missed, the battle begins

both characters will be at there peak strength and durability, they will have access to all there weapons.

LET THE DEBATING BEGIN!!!


Super Buu vs the JJK verse. But he starts out as strong as the weakest character Super Buu vs the JJK verse. But he starts out as strong as the weakest character
Battle

To those who do not know Super Buu is Majin Buu’s third form the one who fought Gotenks and got his ass kicked by Mystic Gohan. This version of Buu actually has intelligence and cunning at his disposal. As he distracted Gotenks and Piccolo by talking to them while his Buu… goo? Crept up on them from behind.

He also goaded Goten and Trunks to becoming SSJ3 Gotenks so he could get the most power possible from them when he absorbed them. Also cursed energy and Ki are the same in this battle so Buu can sense them and they can sense Buu. (If that’s a thing they can do in this verse, I have yet to watch it.)

This version of Buu is very intelligent. (he is a Galexy brain by DBZ standards) He will also get astronomically smarter the more he absorbs people. He absolutely would work his way up the ladder and do things in a way that boosts his chances of victory. Can he play it smart long enough to take down the verse. Or dose someone destroy him before he gets the chance? How many times out of 10 dose he pull it off?








[Dragon Ball Super] Can Bulma kill Yamcha? [Dragon Ball Super] Can Bulma kill Yamcha?
Battle

After Yamcha gets rejected from the tournament of power, he drunkenly calls Bulma and simps too hard; Bulma decides he needs to go. She wants to kill him on her own, nor will she tell anyone about her plans (though others still may find out if she's sloppy).

She has up to three years to plan out her murder plot and of course has access to all her company resources. So can Bulma kill Yamcha?

Round 1: No Dragon Balls

Round2: Dragon Balls are allowed.


Lightsaber fight: Dooku and Windu vs Ser Arthur and Ser Barristan Lightsaber fight: Dooku and Windu vs Ser Arthur and Ser Barristan
Battle

The best swordsmen of Star Wars, Count Dooku (AOTC) and Mace Windu (ROTS), and of Game of Thrones, Ser Arthur Dayne and Ser Barristan Selmy (both in Robert’s Rebellion era as seen in Season 7 flashbacks) face off in a 2v2.

Dooku and Windu cannot use the force and must rely on sabre dueling skills and physical martial arts only.

The knights can choose any sabre type (single blade, double blade, dual wield, etc). And are given enough time to master the weapons.

2v2 engagement, win by killing every member of enemy team.



Tai Lung (Kung-Fu Panda 1) vs. Pearl (Steven Universe season 2) Tai Lung (Kung-Fu Panda 1) vs. Pearl (Steven Universe season 2)
Battle

Both got sucked into portals and got teleported onto the Grand Arena on Sakaar.

Tai Lung just beat the Furious Five on the bridge while he was on the way to beat Po.

Pearl just finished on of her sword training with Connie.

1 scenario: They both get teleported to the arena and have to fight immediately with no prep time or they both die.

2nd scenario: They both get 3 days of prep time in their cells and learn each other backstories/techniques/fighting style.

3rd scenario: Pearl has a week of prep time, Tai lung has none.



NERV (Rebuild of Evangelion) vs Xiliens (Godzilla Final Wars) NERV (Rebuild of Evangelion) vs Xiliens (Godzilla Final Wars)
Battle

Tokyo-3 finds itself under siege, not by Angels, but by aliens with an army of kaiju at their command. Evangelion Units 00, 01, and 02 stand to defend against the onslaught.

The Xilien will send their kaiju in waves. An hour will pass between each wave except between 4 and Final, for the Evangelion's pilots to recuperate, be replugged in if they need to be, and for weaponry to be restocked.

Wave 1: Gigan (Scythes) and Ebirah

Wave 2: Zilla, Kamacuras, and Kumonga

Wave 3: Anguirus, Rodan, and King Caesar

Wave 4: Monster X and Gigan (Chainsaws)

Final Wave: Keizer Ghidorah

Rules:

  • Final Wave will happen immediately after Wave 4.

  • All invaders will arrive at the cities' outskirts except for Wave 4, where Monster X will be in his meteor poised to land at the heart of the city with Gigan showing up beside him after impact, and Final Wave, where Keizer Ghidorah will be Monster X transforming.

  • Rei, Shinji, and Asuka are piloting their respective Eva Units. As they are in Rebuild 2.0.

  • NERV is supplying weaponry and information to the pilots. Any weaponry shown in Rebuild 1.0 and 2.0 is allowed, as well as weaponry from the original series (under the assumption that it was present but not utilized in Rebuild).

  • All in-character.

  • No foreknowledge for either side.

  • NERV's goal is to destroy the invading kaiju. Xiliens' goal is to eliminate Evangelion Units.

  • Asuka will be given the knowledge of how to have Eva-02 enter Beast Mode in Wave 4, provided she is still combat capable.

  • No Awakened Mode for Eva-01, except during the Final Wave if the other two Evas are destroyed and Eva-01 is critically damaged.


Can China's first emperor Qin save Middle-Earth from Mordor? Can China's first emperor Qin save Middle-Earth from Mordor?
Battle

Qin's 1.2 million strong army gets transported right outside of Minas Tirith to defend the city from the coming orc army from Mordor and Minas Morgul. This happens in the movieverse, but its still similar to the books. 250 000 combined forces of Mordor and Morgul orcs, 500 trolls, 20 oliphaunts with 18 000 haradrim foot soldiers and 500k Easterlings. Plus Nine Nazguls. Still, Qin's army outnumbers Sauron's forces with the main Gondor army. Can Qin decimate the invasion force and go all the way through to the Black Gate and destroy the rest of Sauron's army?



Making It Closer: 20 18-year-olds with wooden baseball bats vs. One healthy, adult bull hippopotamus Making It Closer: 20 18-year-olds with wooden baseball bats vs. One healthy, adult bull hippopotamus
Battle

Fight ends with one side standing.

Round 1 - African Savanna (Land)

Round 2 - African Savanna (Starting 20 feet to the right of a river)

The humans are randomly selected.

Who wins?

I hope this isn’t prohibited, as it is not a direct repost of my last one. This does change the playing field dramatically.


How many Tyrion Lannisters would it take to defeat Gimli? How many Tyrion Lannisters would it take to defeat Gimli?
Battle

Gimli must fight an infinite number of Tyrion Lannisters.

  • Every minute, a new Tyrion appears and attacks Gimli

  • If Gimli hasn't defeated the one that spawned the minute prior it's 1v2 and so on

  • Fight takes place in the place where Oberyn fought Gregor

  • Movie feats for all

R1: All are unarmed and unarmored

R2: Both with best armor, Gimli has an axe and all Tyrions have a sword

R3: Gimli and Legolas vs. 10 Jaime Lannisters in Gladiator Arena


Mcu Thanos vs Order of the Phoenix Mcu Thanos vs Order of the Phoenix
Battle

Order of the Phoenix members:

Dumbledore

Mcgonagoll

Hagrid

Flitwick

Snape

Molly

Sirius

Lupin

Tonx

Moody

Kingsley

Harry

Weasley twins

Bill

Charlie

Abeforth

Newt

Tina

Queenie

Credence

Ron

Hermione

Ginny

Luna

Neville

The Battle take place on Titan

Round 1:Mcu Thanos (no stones) vs order of the Phoenix (1 hour prep time)

Round 2 thanos now has power,space,reality and soul stones but the order is helped by avengers and guardian of the galaxy on Titan


Who would win: Carrie Mathison (Homeland) vs. Mitch Rapp (Vince Flynn’s Mitch Rapp series) Who would win: Carrie Mathison (Homeland) vs. Mitch Rapp (Vince Flynn’s Mitch Rapp series)
Battle

SPOILER ALERT FOR THE FINAL SEASON OF HOMELAND!

Mitch Rapp learns of a former CIA officer, Carrie Mathison, who has betrayed the United States and has apparently defected to Russia. He is tasked with locating and capturing and/or killing Mathison.

Breakdown of the combatants and rules:

  1. Mitch Rapp has support of the US intelligence community for his manhunt for Mathison. He owns a Glock pistol, a shotgun and phone jamming equipment.

  2. Carrie had contacts in the Russian government to aid her in evading and/or defeating Mitch Rapp. She has a Glock handgun, an AK-74M assault rifle, an M4 carbine, phone jamming equipment and a Bowie knife.

  3. Rapp has orders to capture or kill Mathison. If capture is deemed unfeasible he is authorized to use lethal force.

  4. Mathison intends to kill Rapp before she can be arrested for her treason.

Can Mitch Rapp defeat Carrie Mathison?